top of page

Content Writing and AI: 3 Reasons Why You Still Need Human Writers and Editors

Is AI really the king of content now? My thoughts on the AI vs Human Writers/Editors debate.

With AI (Artificial Intelligence) being all the rage these days, I’m sure many content creators are asking themselves – do we still have a place in the content marketing industry? After all, if one can simply generate content with a few prompts, why would you need a copywriter for the job?


It’s true that the digital marketing landscape changed almost overnight with the introduction of tools such as ChatGPT. As per Europol, as much as 90% of online content could be AI-generated by 2026. What does that mean for copywriters or copyeditors? Are these roles really as redundant as you may be led to believe? I don’t think so. A cursory look at the content generated by AI is enough to confirm that fact. Let’s review some of the top reasons why AI isn’t exactly a magic lamp for your content writing needs.


It Lacks Personality

This is a no-brainer. A machine cannot conceive original thought. It is only designed to learn and mimic – it’s in the name after all! You can craft the most carefully worded prompts you want but at the end of the day, a robot is going to sound like a robot. That would probably be acceptable to someone looking for shortcuts, but for those who want actual results, AI-generated content simply doesn’t cut it. This is particularly true for brands that want to embed their voice in the content they share.  


Just the other day I was looking up product reviews on Reddit and I came across a lengthy reply that was clearly generated by some kind of AI writing tool. The poster was human, but you could immediately tell the content was not written by one. How do I know this? Because it was so… boring.


Suffice it to say that if you want actual engagement, you need a human behind the screen.


It Rambles

When it comes to AI-generated content, one thing’s for certain: You’ll have to clean it up. A lot. AI’s ability to ramble is frankly impressive and would probably put the most verbose writers to shame. You can ask the tool to compress its responses but there are some things a machine cannot do very effectively. One of those things is knowing when to shut up.


This is where human editors are necessary. They can figure out what to keep and what needs to go so that the final product is crisp and in line with your average reader’s attention span.


It Doesn’t Fact Check


An amusing (and slightly terrifying) side-effect of using AI-based content generators is that they have the tendency to literally make things up. Google AI overviews recently came under fire for the same. You can read all about it here.

Unfortunately, Google isn’t the only culprit here. A few months ago, I was doing some research on behalf of a friend. The goal was to try and identify if genetic disorders could lead to mutism. When I couldn’t find anything specific online, I gave ChatGPT a shot. Lo and behold, I got a whole list of disorders responsible for mutism. The catch? Half of the disorders did not exist and the rest did not cause mutism.


Without a human writer/editor at the helm, AI-generated content can make all sorts of claims. Given that we basically live in the age of misinformation, this can have serious ramifications.

I’m sure newer AI models will try and tackle this issue. But if I were you, I’d still want a person driving the car.


In a Nutshell


Tools like Gemini, ChatGPT, and Jasper are certainly useful and I won’t deny the impact they have had on the content marketing industry. For example, they can help with rough drafts and the pre-idea generation. But if you want content that converts, then you should consider getting a little (re: a lot) human help too.


The way things are going, I imagine human-written content is soon going to be treated like a premium product. If you want to get ahead of that curve, reach out to me, and let’s discuss your content writing needs.


P.S: No AI was used in the creation of this article—just good old-fashioned experience.

© 2024 by Maham Mehdi. Powered and secured by WWix

bottom of page