top of page

The 3X Rent Rule: A Precursor to Homelessness

Considered a safeguard against defaults on rent payments, the oft-used 3X rent rule can actively contribute to homelessness and limit access to affordable housing.

Most of us have or will rent an apartment at some point in our lives. Apartment hunting can be a long and tiresome process. Once we find one, though, there are fresh hurdles that confront us in the form of rental requirements. There are credit checks, background checks, references, and proof of income. Among these, providing proof of income tends to be the biggest challenge. To approve an applicant, landlords require their monthly income to be equivalent to 3 times the rent. For example, if Sarah wants to rent an apartment that costs $1500 a month, she will have to earn at least $4500 a month in order to qualify. Landlords refer to this as the 3X rent rule. On paper, the rule appears to be fairly sound. However, when we take a closer look, we realize that landlords who implement the 3X rent rule can end up discriminating against low-income individuals by limiting their access to housing and creating conditions that lead to homelessness.


Most landlords and property managers would argue in favor of the 3X rent rule. As per Lindy Cobb, a property manager at Windsor Communities in Austin, TX, the purpose of the 3X rent rule is to safeguard against payment defaults and ensure that a tenant can still make rent after paying for groceries, gas, utilities, and other necessities. Cobb emphasizes that the rule works in favor of both landlords and tenants. Landlords get paid on time, and tenants don’t have to stress out about cutting back on basic needs (Cobb). However, we cannot deny that the 3X rent rule exists to protect the interests of landlords over renters and it is vital to examine its role in exacerbating the homelessness crisis.


To begin with, let us address the premise of the 3X rent rule. As per landlords, this rule helps ensure tenants can make rental payments on time without compromising on other necessities. While this is true for the most part, we also need to see the bigger picture. After all, what’s more important – Being able to afford groceries or being able to access housing? Tabatha Pimental, a resident of Yakima would choose housing. Pimental is a mother of two and a breast cancer patient. She has been struggling to rent a suitable place for a year but doesn’t meet the income requirements. She laments that even though she doesn’t earn three times the rent, she can still pay the rent as well as other bills. As per Pimental, “We won't have extra money, but so what? We can live,” (Kenzo Sundeen). Even Lindy Cobb admits that the 3X rent rule can discriminate against lower-income individuals and that tenants who may not meet this income requirement don’t necessarily end up defaulting. For instance, according to Cobb, there have been tenants who did not make 3 times the rent and were required to get a guarantor to sign off on their lease to rent an apartment. When asked if these tenants ever needed the guarantor to step in and pay rent, Cobb confirms that most tenants did not. They made their payments on time despite not making 3 times the rent (Cobb).


Secondly, the disproportionate rise of rents versus income can make the 3X rent rule difficult to enforce, while also ensuring access to affordable housing. According to a study, homelessness can increase because of a rise in rent-to-income ratios (Horowitz et al.). The study reports that a change in rent-to-income ratios is responsible for a change in the rate of homelessness. Moreover, a rise in homelessness is noted when rental costs increase by a percentage that low-income households cannot afford. This is supported by another study that shows evidence of a significant, positive relationship between homelessness and rising rent-to-income ratios (Quigley and Raphael 334). Landlords must keep the disparity between median rents and median household income in mind when using the 3X rent rule. In 2022, rental prices in Austin increased by 13 percent on an annual basis (Searles). In comparison, median household incomes increased by 11 percent (Pagano). A 2 percent gap may seem inconsequential here, but it can make all the difference for low and middle-income households and their ability to qualify for an apartment under the 3X rent rule.


The income requirements laid out under the 3X rent rule also end up creating problems for individuals working minimum-wage jobs. As per one study, a minimum-wage employee would have to work 138 hours a week to be able to rent a two-bedroom home in Texas (Taylor). This is roughly equivalent to 3.5 full-time jobs. The study declares Austin and Round Rock to be the most expensive areas in Texas in this regard with workers required to earn $31.27 per hour to be able to afford a modest home. Meanwhile, the minimum wage is only $7.25. The situation is further complicated by the fact that 50 percent of the most common occupations in Texas offer a median wage that is lower than what one would need to earn to rent a one-bedroom apartment in the state. Realistically, it is impossible for minimum-wage workers to be able to rent an apartment and also meet the income requirements stipulated under the 3X rent rule. As the study puts it, “affordable housing is out of reach in Texas,” and the 3X rent rule is a big reason why.


Overall, the 3X rent rule can create a slew of issues for low and middle-income families. It downplays the need for housing over other material comforts and fails to account for the disparity between average increases in rent and median income. It also makes it hard for minimum-wage workers to be able to secure an apartment.  Landlords must take these factors into account and take on a more holistic


 

Works Cited

Cobb, Lindy. Personal Interview. 18 October 2023.

Horowitz, Alex, et al. “How Housing Costs Drive Levels of Homelessness.” The Pew Charitable Trusts, 22 Aug. 2023, www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/2023/08/22/how-housing-costs-drive-levels-of-homelessness. Accessed 23 Oct. 2023.

Kenzo Sundeen, Jasper. “As Rent Costs Increase, so Does Pressure on Yakima County Renters and Landlords.” Yakima Herald-Republic (WA), 12 Mar. 2023. EBSCOhost, search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=shib&db=n5h&AN=2W63667572157&site=ehost-live&scope=site.

Pagano, Elizabeth. “Federal Income Numbers for Austin Are up, by about 11 Percent.” Austin Monitor, 20 Apr. 2022, www.austinmonitor.com/stories/whispers/federal-income-numbers-for-austin-are-up-by-about-11-percent/.

Quigley, John M., and Steven Raphael. “The Economics of Homelessness: The Evidence from North America.” European Journal of Housing Policy, vol. 1, no. 3, 2001, p. 334, doi:10.1080/14616710110091525.

Searles, Sam. “Austin Rent Increased by 13.5% This Year.” KVUE, 22 Nov. 2022, www.kvue.com/article/money/economy/boomtown-2040/austin-rent-up-by-135/269-0df056c5-957b-4a84-ae7d-7d445989c63b. Accessed 24 Oct. 2023.

Taylor, Anja. “Affordable Housing Is out of Reach in Texas for Low-Wage Workers.” Texas Homeless Network, 17 Aug. 2023, www.thn.org/2023/08/17/oor-texas2023/#. Accessed 23 Oct. 2023.

© 2024 by Maham Mehdi. Powered and secured by WWix

bottom of page